Nick & Norah’s Party
This particular person hid the true gift inside a faux gift. A red herring, if you will. Something meant to initially distract the recipient until they find the real present within. In this case, the giver tricked their partner into thinking they would watch the romantic musical Nick & Norah’s Infinite Playlist and then cuddle.
Then, in a “gotcha” moment, we see a disc for the video game The Last of Us and a note teasing that “there’s beer in the fridge.” While this gives off stereotypical masculinity vibes, if this is what this couple is into, then more power to them. After all, Valentine’s Day is about celebrating your special love in your way.