A Rose By Any Other Name
Before you give someone a compliment you might want to make sure you are talking to the right person. I am sure that Sophia would be flattered by the fact you think she is pretty aesthetically. I’m also sure she will be impressed that you can spell aesthetically.
Not only did you make good use of your extensive vocabulary but you called her pretty. How could it go wrong? Sarah, on the other hand, may not be as interested in how pretty you think Sophia is.