20 Discontinued Foods and Snacks From the ’80s and ’90s We Still Miss

Keebler Magic Middles appeared to be modest shortbread cookies until one bite revealed soft chocolate or peanut-butter filling inside. Their tidy exterior concealed the filling, making the name unusually accurate. Keebler discontinued them years ago, and similar stuffed cookies have never fully satisfied devotees. Recipes circulate online, but recreating that exact crumbly shell and smooth center requires more patience than most people possess when they simply wanted a cookie with a secret after school today.