22 Classic Halloween Candies We Get a Toothache Just Thinking About

You knew candy corn had to be mentioned here. It’s one of the biggest Halloween candies. This waxy candy with a buttery, vanilla taste has been around since the 1880s when it was originally called “chicken feed.” Since then, it resurfaces every year, and someone on Facebook tells you how it belongs in the trash. I like it enough myself, though it’s not my favorite. But this is the Internet, so I either have to love it with all my soul or cast it into the burning lake of fire!