Five Pennies Creamery Ice Cream Pie
Credit: Five Pennies Creamery
These luscious ice cream pies are made by filling a graham cracker crust with homemade hard ice cream. Their Brownie Batter and Brownie Walnut pie will melt in your mouth and your hands. The shop name “Five Pennies,” comes from the owner’s favorite childhood song by Louis Armstrong and Danny Kaye. The shop has 135 different ice cream flavors.