Young Love Was Her First Experience
When Scarlett first met Reynolds, she had a previous relationship with Josh Hartnett. As a result, their sentiments were far too strong when they first met on set of The Black Dahlia. It turned out that their relationship was doomed from the beginning.
Hartnett claims that they were unable to spend enough time together because of their hectic schedules, and this ruined their budding romance. After nearly two years together, they broke up. Scarlett kept the romance a secret at the time, which reflected her later reticence.