Tobey Maguire and Jake Gyllenhaal
These two underrated cuties actually played siblings in the drama “Brothers”. Not only that, but Jake Gyllenhaal, 37, almost replaced Tobey Maguire, 43, in the Spiderman series. It happened when the Spiderman director met with Jake Gyllenhaal when it appeared that Maguire wasn’t going to return for the sequel if he didn’t receive a higher salary. After begging his way back into the franchise, Maguire was paid $17 million to return for the sequel, so his stalling tactics worked and he actually got a $13 million raise.